Disney's Peanut Butter and Jelly Milk Shake

Craving a taste of Disney magic? This copycat Peanut Butter and Jelly Milkshake from Disney's 50s Prime Time Cafe is the perfect nostalgic treat! Creamy, sweet, and packed with PB&J goodness, it's like sipping on your favorite childhood sandwich—blended into a dreamy, delicious milkshake.

This post may contain affiliate links. When you click on these links, I get a small percentage back at no cost to you! For more information see my disclosure policy.

Below you will find tips, tricks and helpful hints for making this recipe including step by step instructions with pictures. If you would like to go directly to the recipe, scroll down to the recipe card or tap "Jump to Recipe" at the top of the page.

Why You'll Love This Milkshake

Picture this: a sip of pure nostalgia mixed with a dash of Disney magic. That’s the vibe you get from the Peanut Butter and Jelly Milkshake—a fun blend of sweet vanilla ice cream, creamy peanut butter, and your choice of strawberry or grape jelly.

This tasty shake is a must-try for anyone looking to relive a bit of childhood nostalgia with a touch of Disney magic. It’s a fan favorite at the 50’s Prime Time Cafe, bringing back memories of simpler times with every sip.

This milkshake really hits the spot for Disney fans and foodies alike. The unique mix of flavors captures that special Disney magic we all love, making it one of those must-try treats people keep raving about. If you are a milkshake lover like me, make sure to also try The Best Strawberry Milkshake or this delicious Blueberry Milkshake!

50's Prime Time Cafe at Disney World

As soon as you step inside, you're hit with a blast of retro charm that feels like a step back in time. The vibe isn’t just about the old-school decor—it's the whole experience, right down to the playful scolding from the servers.

They’ll tell you to “get your elbows off the table!” which adds a fun twist to your meal. Eating at the 50’s Prime Time Cafe isn’t just about the food; it’s about the full-on nostalgia trip.

Surrounded by vintage kitchen gear and cozy dinette sets, you’ll feel like you’re right in the heart of a 1950s family kitchen. The menu is packed with diner classics like chicken noodle soup, pot roast, meatloaf, and crispy fried chicken. It’s a must-do for any Disney trip!

We have loved making our favorite treats at home lately (Churro Bites, Easy Mickey Beignets, Woody’s Grilled Cheese, etc.) and this milk shake is no exception. You can customize it by adding more or less peanut butter, or by using grape jelly instead of strawberry. Your choice!

Milkshake Ingredients

*Ingredient amounts are located in the recipe card at the end of this post.

• Milk: Provides the liquid base for the milkshake, contributing to its creamy texture and helping to blend the other ingredients smoothly.
• Vanilla Ice Cream: Adds richness, creaminess, and sweetness to the milkshake, serving as the primary flavor base.
• Creamy Peanut Butter: Infuses the milkshake with a nutty, savory flavor, complementing the sweetness of the ice cream and jelly. It also adds a velvety texture.
• Strawberry or Grape Jelly: Brings the classic flavors of a peanut butter and jelly sandwich into the milkshake, offering a fruity sweetness and a hint of tartness.
• Whipped Cream: Tops off the milkshake with an airy, indulgent layer of sweetness, enhancing the overall presentation and adding a light texture.
• Maraschino Cherries: Serve as a traditional garnish, providing a pop of color and a sweet, tangy flavor contrast to the creamy milkshake.

Instructions

[Step 1] In a powerful blender, add the milk, ice cream, peanut butter, and jelly.

[Step 2] Blend the ingredients together until completely combined.

[Step 3] Pour the milk shake into a cute milkshake glass and add a fun straw.

[Step 4] Top the peanut butter & jelly milk shake with whipped cream and a cherry if desired!

Helpful Kitchen Tools

• Ice Cream Scoop
• Measuring Cup
• Blender
• Milk Shake Glasses
• Cute Straws

Variations/Substitutions:

• Dairy-Free Option: Substitute dairy-free milk (such as almond milk or oat milk) and dairy-free ice cream to make a vegan or lactose-free version.
• Nut-Free Option: Use a nut-free spread or alternative, such as sunflower seed butter, in place of peanut butter for those with nut allergies.
• Flavor Variations: Experiment with different flavors of ice cream or jelly to create unique variations, such as chocolate ice cream with raspberry jelly or banana ice cream with honey.
• Toppings: Feel free to customize the toppings with additional ingredients like chocolate syrup, sprinkles, or chopped nuts for added flavor and texture.

Frequently Asked Questions

• Can I adjust the peanut butter and jelly quantities? Absolutely! The beauty of this recipe lies in its flexibility. If you're all about that rich, nutty flavor, go ahead and add a smidgen more peanut butter. Or, if you're Team Sweetness, feel free to be generous with the jelly. Whether it's Disney World's charm you're after or the nostalgic vibes of the prime time café, it's all about crafting the perfect blend that makes your taste buds dance.
• What if I prefer a thicker (or thinner) milkshake? To thicken your milkshake, add more ice cream for that creamy, dreamy texture. If you're aiming for a lighter consistency, a splash of milk will do the trick. Remember, Walt Disney himself encouraged imagination, so don't shy away from experimenting to get your milkshake just right.
• Are there dairy-free options? Of course! Swap in your favorite plant-based milk and vegan ice cream to create a dairy-free delight that's just as magical. Disney Parks are all about inclusivity, and this milkshake recipe is no exception.
• Any Disney-themed presentation tips? Oh, where do I start? Serve your milkshake in a souvenir Disney Parks cup if you have one. A dollop of whipped cream, a sprinkle of colorful sprinkles, and a cherry on top can add that extra pizzazz. And don't forget a fun straw! Perhaps, one that you picked up from the Disney cruise line or a prime time café souvenir. It's those little touches that bring the enchanting world of Disney right to your dining table or home studio.

More Disney Recipes:

• Short-Cut Mickey Beignets
• Disney Churro Bites
• Toy Story Land Grilled Cheese
• Easy Mickey Beignets
• Disneyland's Raspberry White Chocolate Chip Cookies
• Disney Park Snacks Recipes
• Mickey-Shaped Treats

Watch the video here:

Did you try this recipe? Make sure to give it a five star ⭐️⭐️⭐️⭐️⭐️ rating below!